Collective guilt is a trap

I just can’t stand this absurd notion of collective guilt.

If I hear one more politician say “We have a long way to go” or “We must confront our racism” or “We must take steps to blah-blah-blah,” I’m going to scream.

Funny, isn’t it?  When an Islamic radical opens fire in a gay nightclub and murders scores of people, politicians and the news media urge us to remember that one cannot condemn an entire religion based on the actions of one person.

If only they applied that to everything else.

One police officer in Minneapolis kneels on a suspect and the suspect dies, suddenly “WE” – every melanin-challenged American from coast-to-coast — are to blame.  Therefore “WE” must condemn ourselves and seek atonement all in this bizarre practice of collective guilt.

No.  Sorry.  No sale.

We are a nation that is founded on the principle of the Individual, not the Collective.

If one man commits a sin, that one man is responsible, not every person of that man’s race, and certainly not “society.”

All this collective guilt crap makes me nuts.

As Jesse Kelly put it yesterday on Twitter:

Collective guilt is a trap

If you feel guilty for things you had no part in, that’s on you.  Don’t bleed your instability all over me.  I have nothing to account for and certainly nothing to apologize for.

I don’t need to “examine my own unconscious bias” or “white privilege.”

Life in America shouldn’t be one gigantic traveling group therapy session, for crying out loud.

It’s self-indulgent, self-destructive and runs counter to ideal that each of us is an individual – responsible for our own actions, choices, successes and failures.

Collective guilt is a trap – a way to indict whole segments of the country for the actions of a few individuals – even if those individuals are long dead.

Along with this nutty collective guilt comes the even nuttier collective atonement.

Just yesterday, a video of Chick-Fil-A CEO Dan Cathy made the rounds on Twitter.  In it, he explains that white people should shine black people’s shoes as a way to express their collective guilt and “embarrassment” for racism.

Because nothing will alleviate your embarrassment like embarrassing yourself.

If Dan Cathy wants to go around shining the shoes or, hell, even washing the feet of black people because he’s so ashamed and embarrassed about racism, he can do it till his hands are cracked and bleeding.

But don’t enlist me in that kind of demoralizing, virtue-signaling nonsense.

The only time I should feel shame is when I personally do something shameful.  Collective guilt isn’t my bag.  So you can peddle that nonsense elsewhere.

I saw a Twitter thread from conservative writer Kira Davis that shows just how kooky and absurd this collective guilt baloney really is.

Check it out:

When I read that third tweet, this was my reaction:

I want to have it put on a plaque and placed at the entrance of every university, corporate headquarters, cable news headquarters, and on the office doors of every member of Congress.

A nation that is built on the foundation of Individual Liberty and Sovereignty should never fall into the trap of collective guilt.

You cannot “fight” against racism — an ideology that collectively judges all people of one race – by collectively condemning all people of one race.

Unless you personally owned slaves or have a deep-seated loathing of a specific race, how in Lucifer’s reach are you guilty of the “sin of slavery” or racism?

You are under no obligation to take on the sins of others.  You’re not Jesus.

Embracing collective guilt does not make you a virtuous person.  It is self-indulgent mummery.

Just stop it.  For your own sanity and the sanity of the people who come in contact with you every day, get off the collective guilt train and get over yourself.

Hit the Tip Jar!

Every dollar makes a difference!  Hit the DONATE button in the side bar.  Or, set up a recurring monthly contribution by choosing SUBSCRIBE.

Please White List Patriot Retort

Not everyone can afford to make a donation.  But you can still help keep this site solvent by white listing in your ad blocker. Ads help pay for this site and ad-blockers hurt that effort.  I made sure that the ads that appear here will not obstruct or interfere with your enjoyment of the content.  So please add to your white list.


Get Dianny’s latest ebook, RANT: Derangement & Resistance in MAGA Country. You can find it at Amazon, Apple iBooksBarnes & Noble Nook Store, and at Smashwords for only $4.99!

Share, share, share

9 thoughts on “Collective guilt is a trap

  • June 19, 2020 at 3:50 pm

    Here here, Dianny.

  • June 19, 2020 at 9:18 pm

    Thank you, Dianny.

  • June 19, 2020 at 11:00 pm

    Well said and much needed!! Bravo!

  • June 20, 2020 at 6:25 am

    I live in a rather special world. I only know one person who apologized. Where they are I don’t know. They’re outside my ken. But sometimes when I’m in a bar I can feel them.
    apologies to Pauline Kael

  • June 20, 2020 at 6:09 pm

    Leftists hate individuals. Their specialty is pandering to “groups” and stirring up hatred and envy and resentment. Hitler used a similar approach by demonizing Jews and Communists. Victims are easy to use. Leftism is PURE EVIL and the Democrats of 2020 are on board. Shame on them.

  • June 20, 2020 at 11:50 pm

    Blaming one particular race for all their problems is the epitome of racism. The ‘sins of the fathers’ is only the excuse being used – this time – to avoid taking responsibility for their own shortcomings.

  • June 21, 2020 at 3:32 am

    I have a theory that the last few weeks have created a lot of racists

  • June 22, 2020 at 7:25 pm

    “The only time I should feel shame is when I personally do something shameful.”

    Welp, this post is a pretty good start. On your knees, bigot, and repent.

    Your inability to recognize the sins of the American culture to this point, reflected in your selfish disregard for the suffering of others, is the crux of the problem. This is literally what the term “systemic” connotes. You have benefited from the unjust treatment of others. It may not be absolutely palpable or direct in your eyes. But it is there. The system has been built that way. To favor a particular race over another – since our nation’s inception. There are countless historical facts to back that up, including up to the very moment that I’m writing these words.
    One question for you: would you trade the way you are treated by law enforcement for the way African-Americans are treated by them?

    • June 22, 2020 at 7:27 pm

      Hahahaha! No. But if you want to don sackcloth and ashes, knock yourself out.

Comments are closed.