Midway is a great movie

Midway is a great movie

If you’re looking for something to watch this weekend, I highly recommend renting the movie Midway.

Since I’ve been sick all week, I decided to treat myself. So I rented it last night.

[I don’t do comfort food; I do comfort movies]

Fact is, when Midway was first released last fall, I assumed it would be a typical Hollywood mess the way the 2001 film Pearl Harbor starring Ben Affleck was.  Boy was that movie awful.

But a couple people whose opinion I trust said good things about Midway, so I thought I’d give it a shot.

And I’m really glad I did.

As a general rule, I love World War Two stories.  Band of BrothersThe Pacific, Hacksaw Ridge – all of those are excellent.

The Battle of Midway is also an important subplot in Herman Wouk’s masterful epic novel “War & Remembrance” (the sequel to “The Winds of War”).  I’ve read those books so many times over the last thirty years, and every time I read the chapters on the Battle of Midway, I think to myself, “Boy would this make an incredible movie.”

And boy, does it.

Much like Wouk’s account, the film doesn’t just recount the American side of the story, but also gives us the perspective from the Japanese side (which means, prepare for subtitles).  Doing that gives Midway much more breadth and depth than your typical Hollywood war picture.

Overall, the film is pretty accurate historically.  There are some liberties, of course, as there always are when historical events become movies.  But it sticks pretty close.

And though the film is about Midway, it also includes what leads up to that pivotal battle.  The Pearl Harbor attack, the Battle of the Coral Sea – where the Japanese and American navies first face one another — and the Doolittle raid on Tokyo.

The special effects are amazing.  The scene of the Pearl Harbor attack, for example, is horrifyingly breathtaking. All that black smoke and fire, the Zeroes diving down and firing on the men aboard the ships — it was like watching the real thing.  And when the Arizona goes down, I actually found myself crying.

[I’m a girl, okay?  Girls cry.]

The actual Midway battle takes up most of the last hour and it’s pretty pulse-pounding.  There were points when I was tensing every muscle in my body as if doing so would somehow help the SBD Dauntless pilots avoid getting shot down while dive bombing their targets.  I don’t know if I helped them any.  But I gave it my best.

Though, I can’t say my terror of flying was helped by those scenes.  If anything, it just confirmed for me that my terror is justified.

The film doesn’t waste a lot of time with silly side-romance stories like the dreadful Affleck Pearl Harbor did.  We get some scenes with the aviators in Hawaii with their wives and children, but they’re used sparingly mostly to give the characters more depth.

And as much as I think Woody Harrelson is a prat, he does a great job as Chester Nimitz  — the Navy Admiral who replaced Husband Kimmel as Commander in Chief of the Pacific Fleet after the Pearl Harbor attack.

Someone else who did a great job is Japanese actor Etsushi Toyokawa who played Admiral Yamamoto. I thought he was really impressive in the role.

But the central characters of Midway are the aviators.  Though, in the beginning, I couldn’t keep straight who was who in the zoo.  Probably if I watch Midway a half dozen times, I wouldn’t have trouble keeping track of them.  But at the same time, not being able to keep track of them at the start of the film didn’t take away from the story at all. Plus, by the time the movie got to the Battle of Midway, I pretty much figured them out.

Midway is definitely worth renting – especially if you, like myself, are a fan of World War Two stories.  It isn’t just some excuse to give whatever straw-haired beefcake actor all the girls are swooning over an excuse to put on a uniform and play a Navy aviator (you know, like Affleck’s Pearl Harbor was).

And maybe that’s why it didn’t bother me that I couldn’t keep track of them at first.  They were a team – not just background players staying out of the way for some highly-paid superstar actor to preen in front of the cameras.

[Can you tell I really hated Pearl Harbor?]

This kept the focus on the real life men these actors were portraying.  And they are portraying the actual heroes of Midway.

The film handles the story in a way that honors and respects the service and sacrifice of those men who had such a pivotal role in turning the tide of the Pacific war.

It’s rare for Hollywood to turn out a good movie nowadays.  And Midway is definitely one of those rare gems that stands out like an aircraft carrier in a sea of Hollywood garbage.

I think you’ll really like it.

Hit the Tip Jar!

Every dollar makes a difference!  Hit the DONATE button in the side bar.  Or, set up a recurring monthly contribution by choosing SUBSCRIBE.

Please White List Patriot Retort

Not everyone can afford to make a donation.  But you can still help keep this site solvent by white listing PatriotRetort.com in your ad blocker. Ads help pay for this site and ad-blockers hurt that effort.  I made sure that the ads that appear here will not obstruct or interfere with your enjoyment of the content.  So please add PatriotRetort.com to your white list.


Get Dianny’s latest ebook, RANT: Derangement & Resistance in MAGA Country. You can find it at Amazon, Apple iBooksBarnes & Noble Nook Store, and at Smashwords for only $4.99!

Share, share, share

12 thoughts on “Midway is a great movie

  • February 29, 2020 at 10:35 am

    And give Nick Jonas FULL MARKS on his role. Albeit limited, very powerful.

  • February 29, 2020 at 11:21 am

    Hi Dianny!

    I too am a WWII nerd and I very much enjoyed this film. You mentioned “War and Remembrance”, did you ever see that television mini-series made in the late 80’s? That series does a pretty good job with the battle of Midway as well. I think they had Toshiro Mifune as Yamamoto.

    • February 29, 2020 at 11:25 am

      I remember watching War & Remembrance when it aired. But since that was over thirty years ago, not much of the mini-series stuck in my mind.

      • February 29, 2020 at 11:28 am

        You can get it on DVD. “The Winds of War” as well.

        • February 29, 2020 at 11:41 am

          I first decided to read “Winds of War” and “War & Remembrance” because of the W&R mini-series. And now that I’ve read both books so many times in the intervening years, I think going back and watching the mini-series at this point would be no fun for me. When books I love are made into movies, I get so persnickety and annoyed when the film version doesn’t match the picture I have in my head when reading the book that I can’t fully enjoy the film version.

          • February 29, 2020 at 4:37 pm

            Actually, the mini-series was very faithful to the books. My only criticism, some of the actors were a little long-in-the-tooth for the roles they played. I think Robert Mitchum was 70 during the filming of War & Remembrance.

  • February 29, 2020 at 11:58 am

    JoJo Rabbit was a wonderful World War II movie too.
    I liked Midway as much as I hated Pearl Harbor. That movie was garbage and hurt me on a personal level as a History teacher.
    I show Pearl Harbor to teach students about bias and how not to make a film for inspiration for my aspiring film maker students…

  • February 29, 2020 at 12:44 pm

    If it has risen to high praise from you, I’ll most likely buy the movie to enjoy over and over! Thanks for the heads up! I enjoyed the first “Midway”, 70ish, can’t remember exact date.
    Due to having three older brothers, (8/10/12 years older) all NAVY, if it floats, I have a keen knowledge of and love for it. Bro’s were on Destroyers, AKA “Tin Cans”, oldest on the Zellars at the tail end of the Korean ‘Conflict’.
    Another love of mine is the Tuskegee Airmen! Spouse goes to the VA Medical Clinic there and I just walk the hallways looking at their amazing story in photos! As you said “ok, I’m a girl. I cried” during The SOTU when the oldest of them was introduced! Oh My, at the PRIDE!!
    Ok enough……Hope you are tons better, on the mend, kicking that thing that ails you to the curb!
    Great article, as always!

  • February 29, 2020 at 6:18 pm

    I have been studying WWII since I was first able to read-I am now almost 70. The only accurate WWII Nvy movie I’ve seen was Tora Tora Tora. Midway was outstanding. I hated the ’70s Midway-faked romance and gun camera film from Europe (I don’t think the Japs flew Messerschmitts at Midway!) and the effects sucked. The CGI in this one was great and, even though I knew what would happen, it kept me on the edge of my seat. The audience at the showing I went to applauded at the end. BTW-I got my Blu-Ray copy this week and have already watched it again.

    • February 29, 2020 at 6:45 pm

      Tora Tora Tora was very good. I haven’t seen that in ages.

      • March 1, 2020 at 6:34 pm

        It was accurate and, to me entertaining. I have it on DVD!

  • February 29, 2020 at 9:45 pm

    Going to see Midway this week; still on the big screen. So glad to be able to read your insightful comments. Thank you!

Comments are closed.